Home Where are we in the cycle? Live Signals How it works Coming Soon Cycle Screener Cycle Dashboard Signal Backtest Live Signals Recession Tracker Liquidity Cycle Hormuz Dashboard Dividend Scanner Stock Comparison Precious Metals WTI vs Brent
North America ▶
South America ▶
Europe ▶
Africa & Middle East ▶
Asia Pacific ▶
All 34+ Exchanges All Scenarios 2008 GFC — All Signals Fire 2020 COVID — Fastest Recovery Sector Rotation Guide Recession Playbook Signycle Research 🌎 Investor Guides Podcasts Watch How it works FAQ About Live Signals →
Sector Comparison · Signycle

Renewables vs Oil — European Energy Cycle Returns Compared

Signycle Research5 min read

The two great European energy investment cycles: oil stocks driven by Brent crude, and renewable energy stocks driven by the EUR 10-year interest rate. Both have produced extraordinary returns — but with very different timing, duration and risk profiles.

The Renewable Energy Cycle (EUR 10-Year Rate Signal)

European renewable energy stocks — Nibe, Verbund, Ørsted, Solaria — are driven primarily by the EUR 10-year rate. When rates fall below 1.5%, the discount rate for long-dated renewable energy cash flows decreases, dramatically increasing the present value of wind and solar projects. The 2014–2023 low-rate cycle produced some of the largest long-term returns in European equity markets.

StockReturnDuration
Solaria (Madrid)+1,400%105 mnd
Nibe (Stockholm)+1,218%105 mnd
Ørsted (Copenhagen)+711%105 mnd
Verbund (Wien)+555%105 mnd

The Oil Cycle (Brent Signal)

Oil stocks are driven by Brent crude — a faster, more volatile cycle than interest rates. The 2020–2022 oil cycle delivered strong returns but over a shorter timeframe. Current status: Brent at — SELL threshold reached as of March 2026.

StockReturnDuration
Aker BP+388%87 mnd
Equinor+196%74 mnd
TotalEnergies+143%74 mnd
Repsol+99%27 mnd

The Verdict

Renewables win on absolute return (Solaria +1,400% vs Aker BP +388%) but the cycles are much longer — 8–10 years vs 3–5 years for oil. Renewables require more patience but reward it generously. Oil cycles are faster and more tradeable. The EUR 10-year rate needs to fall below the BUY threshold of 1.5% for the renewable cycle to flag a new buy signal — see the live rate on its own signal page for where things stand right now. When both that and Brent's SELL threshold are in play at once, it's a signal to wait for the next cycle entry rather than buying either sector today.

See all cycle returns in the backtest tool

Full backtest →
Signal Alerts
Get alerted when signals change
Weekly cycle updates and signal threshold alerts across all 21 macro indicators.
Macro Cycle Intelligence
Where are we in the cycle? 📉 Recession probability: 📈 Market cycle indicator history